Kurdish Azadi is Not for Sale
I was in high school when the American occupation of Iraq began. I remember the months of dramatic media reports and passionate debates that preceded the invasion, and I remember how physically upset I would get at imagining the cost in lives of the invasion.
I remember it was also the first time I learned more about the Kurds. “Look what Saddam did to the Kurds!” warhawks would cry. “Does this man deserve to stay in power?” Even at that young age I could spot the false logic. Yes, the Kurds had suffered immensely, as I quickly learned. But something felt instinctively wrong about using that suffering to promote more suffering. And yet the invasion of Iraq went on.
Unfortunately it is a cruelty of the world that those in power would rather exploit the powerless rather than genuinely empower them. Because Kurds are already vulnerable to human rights abuses, many political players advance their interests by claiming to be vouching for Kurdish interests. This not only advances their cause, but puts yet another roadblock on the path of Kurdish freedom.
For instance, take Gerald A. Honigman. A self proclaimed educator who has “conducted counter-Arab propaganda programs for college youth”, Honigman’s writings are bizarrely racist exaggerations that center around asserting Israel’s claim to the Middle East. Yet Honigman took it upon himself to write an article aggressively defending the Kurdish right to a state. Even a broken clock is right twice a day, and Honigman is absolutely correct that the Kurdish struggle is no less noble or worthy than any Arab struggle. But he exploits this point in order to advocate for his own agenda, to push his own interests, and to conflate support for the Kurds with standing against Arabs and against Palestine. Honigman brings up the Mavi Marmara and the irony of Turkey’s support for Palestine while “while the Turks are slaughtering or subjugating tens of millions of Kurds in Turkey at the same time”. Indeed, the Kurds have more than their share of hypocrisy from the Turkish government; they have no need for a second helping from such “supporters” such as Honigman.
The frustration doesn’t stop there. Not only are the Kurds bounced around like a beach ball by their “supporters”, but they are also used for the dirty tactics of their oppressors as well. PressTV, a media agency sponsored by the Iranian government, is claiming that the entire Kurdish revolt against the Assad regime is simply a plot by the US and the UK. Rather than admit that the Kurds themselves are powerful, rather than give credit to the months of struggle, to the beautiful protests of the Kurdish people in Syria, PressTV instead decided to hide all of that by blaming Kurdish rebellion on foreign agents in order to smear the Syrian revolution. The Kurds have suffered for too long under the Syrian government, and under the Iranian government. For PressTV to then dismiss the entire Kurdish rebellion is an insult to the sacrifices of the Kurds and legitimately dangerous to the Kurdish cause. Should any Arabs or Iranians actually believe PressTV’s remarks, Kurds may be even more vulnerable to human rights abuses at their hands, especially since they are already seen as outsiders by dominant groups.
From whatever side it comes from, the exploitation of the Kurdish cause for a set political agenda is a direct abuse against Kurdish human rights. Justice for one group is never contradictory with another, and anyone who tries to claim otherwise is a fraud. Human rights are human for a reason, and Kurdish human rights, Kurdish azadi is not for sale.
Comments
slm. first of all the kurdish people in turkey aren`t oppressed like the ones in irak, iran or syria. you shouldn`t mix up reality only because you want a free kurdish state. we have some problems we trying to solve, but none of them want to leave turkey. they are our citizens. and it is not like in irak or syria. and the kurdish people are week, the only reason they can beatle is that they get weapon from russia, america and so on. and there are still some fools who belive america would help them while america is only trying to get the power of the area. and i`m convinced even when there would be a state like krudistan you never ever would manage to upright this state for long time, because you even aren`t able to talk to each other in the same language. why did you sleep for 1000 yaers? you say that different powers had separated you n history, but you fighted for this countries with the people in this countries and you didn`t ask for each other for 1000 years. you really feel ashamed for this fucking article. there are so many of you from syria irak aditionally to the kurdish people in turkey we are helping. and we only see the kurdish pkk supporter as outsiders, because they killed so many people in turkey and are still killing. And this separatistic thoughts aren`t coming from inside they are comin freom syria from irak. from all countries where kurdish people are treated badly. But in last times the kurdish got awekend and started to see that the biggest enemy of a kurd are the kurds around them!
This “self-proclaimed educator” of whom you speak taught for almost 3 decades until medical retirement, was flown in to guest lecture on over 3 dozen major universities as well, and his doctoral work on the Kurds has been featured in one of the leading academies for political science in the entire world, Paris’s acclaimed Institut d’Etudes Politiques (Sciences Po) since 1982. His book’s (http://q4j-middle-east.com ) Foreword is written by the President of the Kurdistan National Assembly of Syria and at least 15 major universities all over the world have acquired it so far. Now, while Ms. Boulad enjoys calling Honigman names, it is revealing that she does not point to anything specific that she can dispute factually…and for good reason. Honigman is a very careful scholar, and his work can be validly documented to the moon.
Gerald, I think the fact that you just praised yourself in 3rd person speaks volumes. Your insanely racist articles speak the rest.